The shiny new tech syndrome makes us focus on always wanting to work with the latest greatest AI models, almost by default. And switching away from one of those to something else is then tied to the question if it is as good or better than the frontier model you already use. I know companies who switch between various models based on task considerations, and use a router of some sort in between to seamlessly switch, but it will still be switching between frontier models.

For me some of my use cases for AI cannot go forward in any acceptable way if it means that the context and data for them get send to the companies offering the models where it vanishes out of my control. It means that none of the closed leading models can be considered for them.
This is not just the case for me personally. Any individual mindful of aspects like data protection, jurisdiction tools fall under, autonomy, extraction, transparency, costs and other externalities, and certainly any company anywhere that has to contend with liability and compliance will have the same reservations and considerations.

It means there’s a need to go counter to people’s first reflex to use the largest and best performing model for everything. Because using the latest largest model for everything may well be overkill, although you won’t notice as the true cost gets hidden in subscription tiers. Mostly however because what the best model is or its replacement, is the wrong question when choosing your AI tools.

The right question to answer is not if there’s is another ‘best’ model out there, but if there’s a ‘good enough’ model out there that also addresses your other concerns, where ‘good enough’ is also task specific. What is good enough, though? In the past days I came up with a workable answer for myself.

I spent most of last week in Switzerland, visiting the Swiss Data Space Forum in Lausanne, where AI (running on top of data spaces) was extensively discussed, in the context of the mentioned concerns. Different approaches to addressing those concerns were discussed. Mixes of costly self-owned infrastructure and public and private cloud set-ups, or how Swiss company Anyway, pools your existing hardware to host models locally (something that sounds of interest to my company). One panelist who discussed using AI in a medical setting made a remark that stood out to me: open weight models, the ones they were running on their own infrastructure, are just 6 to 8 weeks behind the closed frontier models in terms of capabilities. Six to eight weeks sounds like it’s on the optimistic end of the scale, but it did make me think. It changed my perspective of what is good enough.

Good enough then is not when one current model is equal or better than another current model. Good enough is when a current model with less baggage, is comparable to another earlier version of a frontier model that gave me acceptable output then.
In my playing with AI models my usage of Claude Code from the fall of 2025 made a real difference (compared to the AI supported coding I did earlier, in 2023 e.g.), so I’ll take that moment as a watershed. Anything that is currently near the level of what Claude Code with Sonnet 4.5 and Opus 4.5. could do at the end of 2025 will do. My current good enough therefore is some current open weights model with a gap of a year or less to current frontier models.

Baggage does not only come from closed models of course. Open weight models by Chinese companies may come under export restrictions at any time for instance, just as their US counterparts. You will also need to run the alternative models in some way, on your own costly iron, or hosted. For hosting providers the same caveats apply as for the closed model providers.

Running a different set-up must also be done in a way that does not disrupt your current working environment, a way that is mostly just pointing your own set-up to another API endpoint with the models you need to interact with.
Which loops back to the routing I mentioned companies doing. I’ve played with fully local models (not good enough in terms of speed and result), and on a VPS (not good enough in terms of speed). So having a well equipped hoster that provides me with a router in the way larger companies have is needed, and at the same time not themselves bring the drawbacks that closed model providers already do. Previously I made some use of Openrouter.ai, a US company that allowed me to switch between models, but does not address any other drawbacks I mentioned.

Today E pointed me to HostYourAI, a Dutch company that emerged out of the founder getting locked-out of Anthropic at some point. It hosts a wide range of models, all usable through an API (or dedicated set-ups if you need), and it can be set to do so fully under single jurisdiction, the EU, and with a processing agreement where it is clear where my data does and does not go.
That is certainly worth trying out, keeping the acceptable gap of 10-12 months in mind, and I can test drive it by changing the API endpoint that Claude Code talks to. I made an account, threw in some Euro’s, and came up with some test cases to select two or three from (things I vibe-coded extensions to in January, and could now do again to compare, the Persona experiment I started in February, the output of the three helper tools I created in April, or the design of knowledge-graphs I did AI assisted over the summer)

I now have a testable approach to using AI for personal use cases I would not use closed model providers for. It doesn’t require running my own infrastructure (too slow or too expensive), I can use hosted infrastructure than can be set to adhere to my requirements w.r.t. data protection and exclusive EU jurisdiction, and I do not have to change my current set-up otherwise. But most of all, I have a measure to select usable open weight models and judge testing them by: comparable capabilities to the frontier models from about a year ago when I thought their output was useful, and compare the output I still have from then with output now.

The past days I was in London to visit the Big Data LDN event and meet with my friend Paolo and his company’s team at Activate Intelligence. It made for interesting contrasts, and those contrasts made the trip worthwhile where the event on its own would not have.

Big Data LDN is a yearly event. I realised as I explored the venue it’s been a long time since I was at a trade fair style event where the focus is on enterprises and business for business sake, as opposed to mostly an exchange of experiences and ideas. That still happened somewhat but it was clearly not the main focus, the program with 280 or so sessions in two days was mostly to ensure all vendors could share something on stage at some point.
Of course next to big data, or rather enterprise data (most data isn’t actually big imo, and what counts as big is ever shifting upwards, data is mostly just messy), AI took most of the attention. Enterprise data serves as input for anything AI.


One of the two halls at the Olympia venue

Back in the ’00s when I visited corporate knowledge management events there were plenty of slides showing complicated overviews of data sources, stores and flows in a company and how adding name-your-brand-here’s knowledge management system would make it easy to manage all of it and use it. The promise was that adding one more technology layer in the mix would finally make everything easy and governable, effortless even, if you were doing it right. If it wasn’t effortless then obviously you weren’t doing it right, and you needed to buy still one more tool or platform.

Two decades on that pattern is still very much the same.
There were plenty of complicated slides trying to show all the many data related technological building blocks. Where there used to be data warehouses and then data lakes as panacea a few years ago, there are now lakehouses added to combine aspects of both and make their contents available to machine learning, and various calls to go ‘beyond’ the lakehouse were heard. You end up with something that still nobody really has a handle on, but don’t worry, AI will finally make everything effortless, by adding an agentic AI layer. AI agents tend to multiply, and that means you need to start adding ‘agent control towers’, and agents make stuff up so you need to provide the right harnesses for them, which also multiply, and manage those, and do a whole bunch of additional logging for auditing and compliance. All that comes with a range of additional tools for your already very complicated information household, adding just more complicatedness and uncertainty about what it all is for.

What will save you is adding just one more thing, or actually two things, the message was. More context and persistent memory for your AI agents. This according to various speakers was the new focus compared to the event last year. Context and memory so that your AI will understand your business. The underlying assumption being that anyone within enterprise actually understands their business themselves, and that it’s just a matter of letting your AI know it too. Nobody does really, understand their business that is, and for evidence look at the sheer volume of back and forth and reporting and analysis and meetings going on that is only dealing with internal flows of data, and those same reports, analysis and meeting notes, to ‘finally’ make things run ‘smoothly’ internally.

Still I learned a bunch of things. How data that used to be for analysis after the fact is now being used for decision making upfront and for actions right now (but without mentioning whether that may require different sorts of data, and silently assuming you can do either with the same data). How data governance is becoming a continuous and real time thing, and observability is of increasing importance (I agree that is highly interesting). About what context and memory for AI is, and that despite calls to not just look at token cost it is often touted as a great reduction in token cost. (Not using AI all over the place also greatly reduces token cost of course.) How everyone builds tools to make other tools by vendors in the booth next to them work better, or coordinate between that and the tools of vendors several booths over. It’s tools and agents all the way down, where there used to be turtles, to make sense of the world. Much of it sounds like coping strategies made of python and markdown to me.

Hearing the lingo, and listening to what was said and what wasn’t was genuinely useful too. The way that terms like (un)structured data, intelligence and knowledge, but never information, are bandied about as if they are precisely defined, meaningfully quantifiable, and all in the same category. That ethics and regulation is always treated as a compliance issue, adding a burden to your logging and auditing needs, and that no one tends to view ethics and compliance as upfront instruments to improve the overall quality of what you’re designing or doing, thus reducing your externalities and their attached risks. Which would greatly reduce internal friction, actually.

That impact is of course the only measure of succes, but hardly anyone goes on to explain what the impact actually has been for them or their clients. Where the externally visible acceleration is, where the non-lineair jump in actual business outcomes, remains opaque. Impacts that do get mentioned are again often about increased volumes of AI deployment against lowered token costs, about the reduced time needed to pump around those internal reports, meeting notes, and analysis so you can now pump around more of them. That is consistent though, because that was true for the KM conferences of old too, and just as much for any big data, data warehousing, data lake event since then until now. Because none of it is designed for real world impact, it is being designed and deployed for internal efficiency. Not to change or innovate your external outputs and how they have influence in the world. It was tiring to see how much of it all comes across as just busywork.

That we are moving from ‘data driven’ to ‘decision centric’ as one panelist remarked. Which sounds good and proper, but didn’t go into how messy our decisions mostly really are, and how it might be difficult to externalise how we come to decisions, or reverse engineer them so that AI agents might do it too.

Some speakers clearly felt something’s off and launched their own small philosophies in response. Some were told by others something’s off, and where it was their children who told them, they were jolted into making slides about it, but not changing their company meaningfully (judging by those same slides) even if it had been years since their kid stated the obvious. Those philosophies tended to stay within the same unchallenged domain assumptions and usually suggested the answer was another technology component or layer for the complicated overview sheet we started out with at the outset. That, or a clever acronym. Any other remaining issues were left as an exercise for ‘leadership’.

Not that I know how all this should be done, but over the years I have come to the conclusion that the problem with doing anything at scale that isn’t physical like assembly lines but informational is, well, scale itself. Regular large scale, as well as the hyped and hyper varieties. This as it is usually approached or assumed as a type of centralisation, which is fruitless as it crumbles in the face of the next change in the status quo in 3, 2, 1… And it tends to ignore the people involved at every step, and the intention or agency they have, which guarantees the type of complexity that reality can roll with but not your lakehouse or agent control tower.

Back to the slides, before I get to the contrast that made it a valuable trip.
With AI front and center, it came as no surprise that many slides were obviously AI generated. With all the tells that Claude has, you know them, phrases like "This is not coincidence. This is a pattern." and "All four are sound. One is different." and "Subheaders of Overstated Importance" followed by a sentence that doesn’t bear it out. It made for overly verbose slides, because Claude likes to spend them tokens. It became funny when speakers hadn’t fully read their generated slides beforehand but had trusted the output blindly. Trust was another big topic of course, but trust is more than ever better harnessing up to the logical endpoint where you’ve made something fully deterministic and fit for regular automation, or, like, just do it yourself. Talking about trusting AI outputs and presenting slides where there are generated sentences that break the logic of your narrative, or drop in additional terms midway that came out of nowhere, I assume from another AI conversation, was funny. Or a random insertion like ‘The other ten are not’ while recounting a list of four things. Kudos to all those speakers, even when they were clearly spooked a bit by what they found on their own slides, for making nonsensical bridges, or jumping over the misaligned bits as if the slide didn’t exist, and generally getting away with it. Good enough, they’ll have thought.

I stayed on through the entire first day, and over lunch met someone who had already arrived at similar conclusions as above, just much faster, but on the second day I acutely felt the diminishing returns of staying longer and walked out well before lunch time. I strolled the ten minutes or so down the road to Holland Park, with a short detour through the adjacent Design Museum, and sat under a tree in fresh air and gorgeous weather, being stared at by both a crow and a squirrel waiting to see if I had anything edible in my backpack that I cared to share or leave crumbs of.


Watchful eyes while I’m in the park

The trip was valuable, despite my 1500 word rant you just waded through, because of context and memory. They definitely had the importance of context and memory right at the event.
I spent the late afternoon and early evening of the second day with the team of Activate Intelligence, the company of my friend Paolo, placing it in context with my Big Data LDN visit. His team consists of very bright mostly young people that like my own team seem so much more capable and driven than I ever was at their age. Paolo and I go back a very long time (2003), and as I was in knowledge management from a change perspective then, he was into vector graphs and ontologies. Remembering that early work and especially what wasn’t possible then, because it depended on people being extremely consistent in e.g. providing metadata (tags etc.), made him see early on what LLMs might mean. The focus of the tools they build, and how they deploy AI agents is both aimed internally and externally. For both it is about doing two things. The first is that anything they build is geared towards making a professional and their team as a whole more effective, by supporting them. People aren’t there to support the process, the process is to support the professional. The second is that AI is being used to do things that would otherwise be too cumbersome or costly to be useful to do by hand internally or do at all. In a previous conversation with Paolo, we talked about this in terms of tasks underneath the Coasean floor. Here AI is not a substitute for existing human tasks, but used for new types of tasks that are not being done yet because they would otherwise require too much of a coordination burden. This makes it possible to do things with small teams that previously would require a bigger size to be able to cover the associated overhead costs, as well as things that would require too much coordination for any use case. This contrast, enterprises aiming to reduce internal size and friction, albeit by adding new layers of it, for the same external outcome, versus small teams working towards the largest external outcome while avoiding or obviating the need of becoming a sizeable enterprise stands out. Also because its respective directions and pressures ultimately point to the same thing, I think, in bringing the Coasean ceiling, i.e. the maximum expected useful size of an enterprise, down. Paolo wondered how many floors of London’s high rise office towers would go dark in the coming time because of it. That seems promising in a way too, that where trust busting does not currently succeed much in the informational realm, it may well become ineffective to be that big with swarms of smaller efforts delivering the same or better. Why build an enterprise above a certain size, a 19th century slow AI, if you can have the faster 21st century version at team or individual scale without all the hassle?

European Data Protection makes it illegal to transfer person identifiable data to outside the EU. Unless there is equivalence in data protection, or an agreement with guarantees and oversight deemed adequate. For the USA this is the EU-US Data Privacy Framework (DPF). This framework depends on the existence of the independent oversight body FTC, and the Data Protection Review Court (DPRC) which serves as redress mechanism. The arrangement is in place since 2023.

Earlier agreements, the Safe Harbor Agreement (until 2015) and the Privacy Shield Agreement (until 2020), both were struck down in European courts as inadequate (the Schrems I and Schrems II cases).

The DPF always has been a sham. Because in reality it was clear that there was no practical adequacy in any way, let alone that it could be properly enforced. “But there’s independent oversight! The FTC!” has been used as plausible reason to change nothing in practice. Notions of data protection in the USA never aligned with the very different premises of the EU GDPR, and wrapping it in the DPF does not change that. Not even when paying no attention to the intelligence elephant in the room.

The semblance of a functional redress mechanism was already gone when the Trump regime fired most of the DPRC members in early 2025, leaving a single Republican in place where three people are needed for a decision. This placed the framework ‘in doubt’. Harsh words, I know.

The death of the DPR has now been made official by the Supreme Court as it destroyed the independence of the FTC by declaring statutory removal protections unconstitutional. That will wreak havoc in the USA itself no doubt, giving the executive control of all heretofore independent oversight bodies (except for the Federal Reserve to add a bit of inconsistency).
Doing away with the FTC’s independence removes the last pretence of a functioning EU – US Data Privacy Framework.

NOYB, the NGO run by Max Schrems (of the epynomous Schrems I and II verdicts) has called upon the European Commission (PDF) to face the facts and withdraw the adequacy decision about the DPF. It has also announced another lawsuit to ensure the DPF will not remain in place if the EC does not choose to act.

The period of the European Commission that has just finished delivered an ambitious and coherent legal framework for both the single digital market and the single market for data, based on the digital and data strategies the EU formulated. Those laws, such as the Data Governance Act, Data Act, High Value Data implementing regulation and the AI Act are all finished and in force (if not always fully in application). This means efforts are now switching to implementation. The detailed programme of the next European Commission, now being formed, isn’t known yet. Big new legislation efforts in this area are however not expected.

This summer Ursula von der Leyen, the incoming chairperson of the Commission has presented the political guidelines. In it you can find what the EC will pay attention to in the coming years in the field of data and digitisation.

Data and digital are geopolitical in nature
The guidelines underline the geopolitical nature of both digitisation and data. The EU will therefore seek to modernise and strengthen international institutions and processes. It is noted that outside influence in regular policy domains has become a more common instrument in geopolitics. Data and transparency are likely tools to keep a level headed view of what’s going on for real. Data also is crucial in driving several technology developments, such as in AI and digital twins.

European Climate Adaptation Plan Built on Data
The EU will increase their focus on mapping risks and preparedness w.r.t. natural disasters and their impact on infrastructure, energy, food security, water, land use both in cities and in rural areas, as well as early warning systems. This is sure to contain a large data component, a role for the Green Deal Data Space (for which the implementation phase will start soon, now the preparatory phase has been completed) and the climate change digital twin of the earth (DestinE, for which the first phase has been delivered). Climate and environment are the areas where already before the EC emphasised the close connection between digitisation and data and the ability to achieve European climate and environmental goals.

AI trained with data
Garbage in, garbage out: access to enough high quality data is crucial to all AI development, en therefore data will play a role in all AI plans from the Commission.

An Apply AI Strategy was announced, aimed at sectoral AI applications (in industry, public services or healthcare e.g.). The direction here is towards smaller models, squarely aimed at specific questions or tasks, in the context of specific sectors. This requires the availability and responsible access to data in these sectors, in which the European common data spaces will play a key role.

In the first half of 2025 an AI Factories Initiative will be launched. This is meant to provide SME’s and newly starting companies with access to the computing power of the European supercomputing network, for AI applications.

There will also be an European AI Research Council, dubbed a ‘CERN for AI’, in which knowledge, resources, money, people, and data.

Focus on implementing data regulations
The make the above possible a coherent and consistent implementation of the existing data rules from the previous Commission period is crucial. Useful explanations and translations of the rules for companies and public sector bodies is needed, to allow for seamless data usage across Europe and at scale. This within the rules for data protection and information security that equally apply. The directorate within the Commission that is responsible for data, DG Connect, sees their task for the coming years a mainly being ensuring the consistent implementation of the new laws from the last few years. The implementation of the GDPR until 2018 is seen as an example where such consistency was lacking.

European Data Union
The political guidelines announce a strategy for a European Data Union. Aimed at better and more detailed explanations of the existing regulations, and above all the actual availability and usage of data, it reinforces the measure of success the data strategy already used: the socio-economic impact of data usage. This means involving SME’s at a much larger volume, and in this context also the difference between such SME’s and large data users outside of the EU is specifically mentioned. This Data Union is a new label and a new emphasis on what the European Data Strategy already seeks to do, the creation of a single market for data, meaning a freedom of movement for people, goods, capital and data. That Data Strategy forms a consistent whole with the digital strategy of which the Digital Markets Act, Digital Services Act and AI Act are part. That coherence will be maintained.

My work: ensuring that implementation and normalisation is informed by good practice
In 2020 I helped write what is now the High Value Data implementing regulation, and in the past years my role has been tracking and explaining the many EU digital and data regulations initiatives on behalf of the main Dutch government holders of geo-data. Not just in terms of new requirements, but with an accent on the new instruments and affordances those rules create. The new instruments allow new agency of different stakeholder groups, and new opportunities for societal impact come from them.
The phase shift from regulation to implementation provides an opportunity to influence how the new rules get applied in practice, for instance in the common European data spaces. Which compelling cases of data use can have an impact on implementation process, can help set the tone or even have a normalisation effect? I’m certain practice can play a role like this, but it takes bringing those practical experiences to a wider European network. Good examples help keep the actual goal of socio-economic impact in sight, and means you can argue from tangible experience in your interactions.

My work for Geonovum the coming time is aimed at this phase shift. I already helped them take on a role in the coming implementation of the Green Deal Data Space, and I’m now exploring other related efforts. I’m also assisting the Ministry for the Interior in formulating guidance for public sector bodies and data users on how to deal with the chapter of the Data Governance Act that allows for the use (but not the sharing) of protected data held by the public sector. Personally I’m also seeking ways to increase the involvement of civil society organisations in this area.

Favorited EDPB Urgent Binding Decision on processing of personal data for behavioural advertising by Meta by EDPB

This is very good news. The European Data Protection Board, at the request of the Norwegian DPA, has issued a binding decision instructing the Irish DPA and banning the processing of personal data for behavioural targeting by Meta. Meta must cease processing data within two weeks. Norway already concluded a few years ago that adtech is mostly illegal, but European cases based on the 2018 GDPR moved through the system at a glacial pace, in part because of a co-opted and dysfunctional Irish Data Protection Board. Meta’s ‘pay for privacy‘ ploy is also torpedoed with this decision. This is grounds for celebration, even if this will likely lead to legal challenges first. And it is grounds for congratulations to NOYB and Max Schrems whose complaints filed the first minute the GDPR enforcement started in 2018 kicked of the process of which this is a result.

…take, within two weeks, final measures regarding Meta Ireland Limited (Meta IE) and to impose a ban on the processing of personal data for behavioural advertising on the legal bases of contract and legitimate interest across the entire European Economic Area (EEA).

European Data Protection Board

Een paar weken geleden had ik een gesprek van een uur met Bart Ensink van Little Rocket over mijn werk en mijn bedrijf The Green Land. Dat gesprek is als zesde aflevering van de Datadriftig podcast nu te beluisteren. We ‘kwamen elkaar tegen’ in de interactie op een draadje op Mastodon in december. Little Rocket is een ebusiness bedrijf en maakt voor hun zakelijke klanten data bruikbaarder. Het is gevestigd in Enschede, dus bracht ik een bezoek aan de stad waar ik tot 6 jaar geleden woonde, en dook Enschede en de Universiteit Twente vaker op in het gesprek.