Continuing the explorations of what trust is, Julian Elv�, the author of Synesthesia, picks up on my discussion with Gary Lawrence Murphy and adds his own thoughts and questions on how to bring Gary’s view and mine under one hat.
I wrote a lengthy comment on his post which I won’t bother to reword here, so I’ll just quote it verbatim:
Hi Julian, Thanks for giving this discussion (the first topic I blogged on!) a new jolt with your contribution. You’ve guessed rightly that I too make trust based decisions on gut feeling most of the time. The only time I always consciously look for patterns of consistent behaviour is when I have a feeling that there’s something rotten in the state of Denmark. But there’s more to it than that for me.
As you suggest, I’m getting more and more convinced that Gary’s position and mine are not at all mutually exclusive. It’s more like the same thing but on different levels in ourselves. This being said, I have to add two remarks that will probably clarify my personal take on this some more.
First off, my exploratory writing on trust started out from the question how my
behaviour, and the structure of the organisation I work in, might influence the
trust involved in our relations with others (clients, organisations etc.), and how to consciously address those effects. Hence my accent on pro-active and conscious actions. Second, from early childhood on I have been very empathic. I, though I did not realise it then, could sense other peoples emotions very well, although I could not understand those emotions because of my age. When talking about my interpretations of what I sensed, people told me not to repeat what others had ‘said’ to me , or what I ‘overheard’ and which I didn’t understand. Apparently there was something ‘wrong’ with my senses, or at least in using them. That’s when I started putting a lot of thought into rationalizing things.
As an adult I had a hard time bringing these two things together again, learning
to trust my own emotions and senses again, and at the same time keeping the
considerable power of rationality at my disposal as well. Or in Gary’s words
I’ve been trying how to learn this: “The more correct response is, IMHO, that
while our brain colours our perceptions, humans are so blazingly successful on
this planet because we can (not that we do, just that we can) transcend our
physiology (when it’s appropriate!) to reach for higher conclusions”
What is also at stake here (and then I’ll stop writing for now) is what made me side step Gary at first: the fear of accepting that something so powerful and
purposeful as rational thinking, could be based on, originated from, or even be
tied back to back with animalistic hunches, intuitions and gut feelings. I am
currently reading Daniel C. Dennet’s ‘Darwins Dangerous Idea’that makes an
enormously strong case to do away with that fear that this origin should in some
way taint the wonder of conscious thought, and makes it possible to the ratio in
me to still enjoy that wonder while also embracing the above.
Kind regards, Ton
On your question how to reflect emotions and trust etc in text on the net;
apparently my solution is writing long texts trying to convey all the relevant
points I wish to relate to you.

In recent months I have spend
time regularly on trust and its implications for knowledge management. This has
all been sparked by a article of John Moore on the value of trust. Only last
week a whole new Trust Special
Interest Group on KnowledgeBoard.com
has been started, which John moderates,
since the topic had become too large to be just a part of the Emotional
Intelligence SIG. A must-go-see for all who are interested in trust. Also I
wrote an article on the role of trust
in knowledge management
myself, and among the people reacting to it, was
Frank Kouwe, who is knowledge manager with Waterschap De Dommel, a semi-governmental
institute for regional watermanagement. Last Friday we met and discussed how to
go about getting a picture of trustflows in his organisation. A sort of
temperature reading of trust. As I work for a company that deals with developing
questionnaires, e.g. for employee satisfaction measurement, it seemed likely to
start from there. Normally these types of research address communicational and
leadership issues in a company, topics which can also be viewed from a Trust
point of view. Both leadership and communication probably have large trust
components build into them. We strongly suspected that trust is not something
you can ask about directly. Either you won’t get useable answers because the
questions get too abstract, or people will give answers that seem desireable. So
how to ask about trust in questionaires? We came up with the following points:

  • Give examples and ask what one what would do given this situation. (e.g.
    Say, you don’t trust a colleague, how would that affect your actions?)
  • Ask questions that address not only the existence but also the absence of
    trust or distrust.
  • Ask what people think are trust generating actions, and also ask whether
    they encounter them often or not within the organisation
  • Ask questions that give an indication of the general world view of the
    person, as the discussion until now seems to indicate that there are people with
    generally trusting views and generally distrusting views of the world.
  • Ask questions that address (organisational) change since this relates to the
    previous point. This from the assumption that trust is openminded, forward
    looking, and distrust correlates with stagnation, maintaining status quo, and
    looking back.
  • Ask about opposing interests between people
    making trust visible
    Apart from asking questions,
    you can also try to conduct a survey to do social network analysis, one making
    an inventory of contacts people have, another doing the same for the people they
    trust the most. This would give you a picture of where personal relationships in
    your company are sparse, or where trusted people also form important nodes in
    the social network. These people could be important trust ‘hubs’ in your
    organisation. (“I trust John, because Peter trusts him, and I already trust
    Peter”, where Peter is the trust ‘hub’) A third approach to mapping trust could
    be looking at incongruency between formal and informal structures in your
    organisation, and also looking at what happens at boundaries between different
    parts of your organisation. What messages are organisational structures giving
    your people. For instance if you’ve put your support desk in the basement behind
    the boiler room, what are you telling your people about the amount of support
    they can trust on getting from you(r organisation)? Other structures to be
    examined in this sense are measurements and reward systems. Are they having side
    effects as trust-creating or trust-destroying messages to your people? Using an
    idea from Chris Macrae, you could also try and map opposing interests and
    blockades between parts of the organisation. By charting what obligations and
    promises part of an organisations has to meet and keep, and then looking at
    where keeping one promise leads to breaking another promise, you’ll probably
    find trust undermining structures in your organisation. The above is the result
    of talking for an hour or so, and certainly needs more work to be useful. I’ll
    keep you informed of how we will move forward from here.