Peter has experimented for a while with Mastodon (and the ActivityPub protocol behind it) and decided that it’s not for him.
Well, this has been fun, but it turns out that the effort-vs-reward for the fediverse doesn’t balance for me; I need fewer reasons to be tethered, not more. @mastohost, recommended by @ton, was an excellent playground. In 24 hours this account will self-destruct. But, now and forever, https://ruk.ca is where you’ll find me.
I very much recognise his point. The disbalance he mentions I felt strongly in the past month, where it was absent in the five and a half years before it. The enormous influx of people, positive in itself, and the resulting growth in the number of people I followed made my timeline too busy. In response I started following topics more and am evaluating rss feeds from ActivityPub servers. The disbalance expresses itself in spending too much time in the home timeline, without that resulting in notable things. (I mean literally notable, as in taking notes) Unlike my feedreader. It does result in some interesting conversations. However such interactions usually start from a blogpost that I share. Because of the newness of AP and Mastodon to the large wave of people joining, many posts including mine are of the ‘Using Mastodon to talk about Mastodon’ type. This is of course common for newly adopted tools, and I still have a category on this blog for metablogging, as blogging about blogging has been a 20 year long pattern here. Yet it is also tiring because it is mostly noise, including the whole kindergarten level discussions between petty admins defederating each other. There’s a very serious discussion to be had about moderation, blocks and defederation, to turn it into a tool that provides agency to individual users and the groups they are part of. These tools are important, and I’m glad I have them at my disposal. Ironically such serious discussion about Mastodon isn’t easy to conduct in a Tweetdeck and Twitter style interface, such as Mastodon provides. I moved the home timeline over to the right in my Mastodon web interface, so I don’t see it as the first thing when I open it up. I’ve concluded I need to step away from timeline overwhelm. Much as I did on Twitter years ago.
A tired purple mastodont lies on the ground sleeping while groups of people are talking in the background, sketchbook style. Dall-E generated image.
There are however two distinct aspects about AP and the recent incoming wave of people that I am more interested to be engaged with than I was before this started.
First, to experiment personally with AP itself, and if possible with the less known Activities that AP could support, e.g. travel and check-ins. This as an extension of my personal site in areas that WordPress, OPML and RSS currently can’t provide to me. This increases my own agency, by adding affordances to my site. This in time may mean I won’t be hosting or self-hosting my personal Mastodon instance. (See my current fediverse activities)
Second, to volunteer for governance related topics in the wider Dutch user group of Mastodon. Regardless of my own use of Mastodon, it is an environment in which many more people than before have new choices to make w.r.t. taking their online presence and tools in their own hands. A step from a global silo such as Twitter to e.g. a larger Dutch instance, while not the same as running one’s own, can be a significant step to more personal agency and networked agency. I’m involved in a group discussing how to establish governance structures that can provide continuity to the Dutch instance Mastodon.nl, lets people on the instance have an active voice and role in its internal governance, and raises awareness of the variety of tools and possibilites out there while purposefully avoiding becoming a new silo (through e.g. providing pathways away from the instance). Such governance is not part of the Mastodon instance, but structured around it. Such involvement is an expression of my experience and role in using tech for the past 33 years online as being inherently political.
A purple mastodont is conversing with a crowd of people, sketchbook style. Dall-E generated image.
De term “Timeline Fatigue” vind ik herkenbaar. Alhoewel sympathieker (en beter opgezet) is Mastodon toch weer een extra tijdslijn om door te scrollen. Soms leuk, interessant, maar ook met dwangmatige posters, klagers, groepsrituelen. Allemaal iets subtieler en frisser in vergelijking met de oude site, maar in mijn ervaring toch ook weer niet zo verschillend. Ik heb zeker last van “Timeline Fatigue”. Zo leuk en opwindend als “sociaal” was in het begin (voor mij Flickr) is het zeker niet.
Het heeft voor mij wel ook te maken met volume en tempo. Toen Flickr nog klein was, en Twitter, was het daar ook goed toeven voor interactie. Dat gevoel had ik tot vorige maand in Mastodon ook. Behapbare hoeveelheden berichten die voorbij komen, weinig gekrakeel. Nu voelt dat anders. In een stadion vol mensen gaat het er nou eenmaal anders aan toe dan in een half gevulde kroeg. Ik vraag me af of je het lastiger kunt maken om je in ieder gesprek te mengen, zonder te knagen aan de mogelijkheid met iedereen in contact te treden.