« Building trusting relationships from blogging | Main | The Role of Blogs, continued....... »

Debate, dialogue and humour

Yesterday I was at the `Night of Philosophy` in Felix Meritis in Amsterdam. From
that evening I took two observations home. First Peter van der Geer, made a
remark on the relation between debate and dialogue. Earlier on I wrote on debate and dialogue as opposites. He said that debate is a precursor, not an opposite, for dialogue. You have to switch to dialogue as soon as the debate has come upon questions that cannot be answered by debating them. Then the debaters have to engage in dialogue together to be able to move forward.

Simon Critchley

Second, I listened to an interview with British philosopher Simon Critchley (see profile at Essex
University
talking about his 2002 book on humour. (see On Humour, at Amazon)

There are historically three theories of humour:

  • The superiority-theory, as in where someone slips on a banana peel and
    surrounding bystanders laugh at the unhappy soul. This is I think an act of
    creating a sensis communis by excluding others. Defining a group by saying who is not part of it.
  • The relief-theory, where humour is used to relief emotions or tension, like
    making a light joke during stressful moments, e.g. when hiding in a Baghdad air
    raid shelter.
  • The incongruity-theory. In this last instance humour is used to put things
    upside down, to brake through patterns. It remembers me of Wittgensteins
    language-games where words take on different meanings in different
    contextualities.

    Now according to Simon Critchley using the last form of humour is at its root a philosophical act. This because it involves reflection upon the self, the other and the world. He cited self-ridicule as an example of this. I would say, self ridicule could also be a form of self-directed superiority humour. Which, as Critchley added, can also be a means of establishing your authority: I am so powerfull that I can make jokes about myself. In the incongruity variety self ridicule shows that you feel comfortable enough to show weaknesses or be more vulnerable. But these are of course two sides of the same coin, as they mainly differ in nuance and intention.

    After the interview we talked a few minutes about humour and knowledge management. Having fun and laughing is said to be useful for enhancing creativity, and facilitating the correct atmosphere for dialogue, by KM pros. Would humour in this case be a facilitator, a catalyst, or also a method in itself?

    First off, humour helps bring forward the informal structures in more formal settings. Self ridicule as said above can help bringing down authority and hierarchical structures. Also the relief kind can help solve tense situations in discussions and debates (as a step up to dialogue?). But the incongruity type of humour is also an expression of creativity itself. It takes creativity after all to put a situation in a different light. And that is what the desired effect of creativity is: looking at situations from another angle, in another context, in order to discover new and alternative roads forward. It’s the need to jump ahead, when evolutionary progress is exhausted. Irrationality as a means to help rationality forward. It’s the classic boundary that scientific progress encounters and has to overcome time and again.

    Permalink

    Nacht van de filosofie
    Excerpt: In het kennismanagement weblog schreef ik op 6 april het volgende:[Ton's Interdependent Thoughts]Yesterday I was at the `Night of Philosophy` in Felix Meritis in Amsterdam. From that evening I took two observations home.First Peter van der Geer, made a...
    Weblog: Ton|noT ities
    Tracked: June 25, 2003 09:57 PM

    Post a comment










    Remember personal info?






  • About

    ton2small.jpg Weblog by Ton Zijlstra,
    Enschede, Netherlands
    I write about knowledge work and management, and the tools and strategies that help us navigate the networked world.
    Contacting me is easy and appreciated:
    E-mail, Skype, MSN

    Syndication:
    Full posts
    Excerpts

    Interdependent Thoughts in Dutch and German:
    RSS Nederlands
    RSS Deutsch

    Where I am

    MSN: MSN Online Status Indicator
    Yahoo: Yahoo Online Status Indicator
    Skype:
    AIM: AIM Online Status Indicator
    ICQ: ICQ Online Status Indicator
    Plazes: Where is Ton?

    Archives


    May 2007
    April 2007
    March 2007
    February 2007
    January 2007
    December 2006
    November 2006
    October 2006
    September 2006
    August 2006
    July 2006
    June 2006
    May 2006
    April 2006
    March 2006
    February 2006
    January 2006
    December 2005
    November 2005
    October 2005
    September 2005
    August 2005
    July 2005
    June 2005
    May 2005
    April 2005
    March 2005
    February 2005
    January 2005
    December 2004
    November 2004
    October 2004
    September 2004
    August 2004
    July 2004
    June 2004
    May 2004
    April 2004
    March 2004
    February 2004
    January 2004
    December 2003
    November 2003
    October 2003
    September 2003
    August 2003
    July 2003
    June 2003
    May 2003
    April 2003
    March 2003
    February 2003
    January 2003
    December 2002
    November 2002

    Bookblog


    (last 2 entries) (rss)

    Books I read


    Authentic voices


    Lilia Efimova *
    Martin Roell *

    Gary Murphy
    Seb Paquet *

    Sebastian Fiedler *
    Frank Patrick

    Thomas Burg *
    Ross Mayfield

    Terry Frazier
    David Weinberger *

    Dina Mehta *
    Rick Klau

    Stuart Henshall *
    Elizabeth Lawley

    Spike Hall
    Andy Boyd *

    Phil Wolff *
    Matt Mower *

    Jim McGee
    Olaf Brugman *

    David Gurteen *
    Johnnie Moore *

    Elmine Wijnia *
    David Pollard

    Julian Elvé
    David Buchan

    Denham Grey
    Judith Meskill

    Ian Glendinning
    George Por *

    Paul Goodison
    Jack Yan

    * met face to face


    Miscellaneous

    Technorati Profile

    Powered by Movable Type and Qumana
    i_use_qumana.png



    Creative Commons License
    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.